March Discussion: The Mandarins by Simone de Beauvoir

Hi fellow readers,

I’m going to do this month a little differently. For March’s book, The Mandarins by Simone de Beauvoir, I’m going to have a single discussion thread (this post) that we can come back to whenever we want to comment. That will help keep the conversation lively and accommodate everyone’s reading speeds, and it won’t break the conversation up as much as separate posts did.


After you’ve read a little bit in The Mandarins, come back to this post and start a conversation. Ask something you wondered about during your reading, or formulate a question to start a conversation on something in the book that caught your interest. You can ask more than one question.

After you ask your question, go answer someone else’s!


P.S., please excuse my silence in the latter half of February. I was having a health crisis that kept me from doing a lot of things, this book club among them. I’m feeling better now, so I hope things will be getting back to normal soon.

Open Discussion: Do you think Jubilee would be different if it was published today?

No matter who writes a book, it always comes to the reader filtered by time and the gatekeepers of publication.

With that in mind, do you think Jubilee would be different if it was published today? In what ways might the novel be different?

View 5 comments →

📚 Open Discussion: Jubilee by Margaret Walker 📚

It’s your turn to ask the questions. Ask something you wondered about during your reading, or formulate a question to start a conversation on something in the book that caught your interest. You can ask more than one question.

After you ask your question, go answer someone else’s!

Jubilee is still on sale on Amazon for $2.99. Get it here, if you haven’t already.

View 24 comments →

📚 Welcome to February. Here's Our Next Book 📚

Hi readers!

Welcome to February. We’re officially finished with Middlemarch, and it’s time for a new book. That said, if you’re still on Middlemarch and you want to keep reading, keep reading! I can schedule some open all-book reading discussions later.

What did I think of Middlemarch? Well, I liked it, but it wasn’t my favorite. I have a difficult time making connections with characters when there are so many of them. I would have loved a more central narrator to ground everyone’s story. Even though we did have a strong narrator with Middlemarch, she didn’t come forward as a character like some of us wanted her to. But that’s fine.

So why am I sharing that I didn’t really like the book? Well, I’d like to give this book club an atmosphere of freedom. I’ve been a part of too many reading groups where it seemed like we were required to like every book we read to qualify as book lovers. But that’s total nonsense. So at Doorstopper, I encourage you to share how you really feel about the books we read as long as you aren’t attacking people who enjoyed the books. You all have been doing a good job with that already. Keep being yourselves, and don’t feel like you need to be sunny and positive if you want to participate. One of the beauties of reading classics is that we can share our opinions without the writer hunting us down on social media.

I’ll circle back to the older discussions soon to make sure I responded to everyone. Now, to our February read!

Our February book is Jubilee by Margaret Walker.

Jubilee (50th Anniversary Edition) by [Walker, Margaret]

Several people have described Jubilee to me as an antidote to Gone with the Wind. Walker, who passed away in 1998, was a scholar of black history and culture, in other words, exactly the person to tell an important story that has frequently been co-opted and romanticized.

Here’s a description:

“Jubilee tells the true story of Vyry, the child of a white plantation owner and his black mistress. Vyry bears witness to the South’s antebellum opulence and to its brutality, its wartime ruin, and the promises of Reconstruction. Weaving her own family’s oral history with thirty years of research, Margaret Walker’s novel brings the everyday experiences of slaves to light. Jubilee churns with the hunger, the hymns, the struggles, and the very breath of American history.”

Even though the subject matter is heavy, Walker’s prose and storytelling deliver this historical moment in a lighter package, making Jubilee a much-needed respite after Middlemarch.

Jubilee is on sale on Amazon for $2.99. Get it here.

Our first discussion on Jubilee will be this coming Saturday. This time, I’d like to do it a bit differently. As you’re reading, think of a question you’d like to ask the group. It can be something you don’t know about the text, or it can act as a conversation starter to introduce something you’d like to talk about.

As always, thanks for reading with me.

~ Rebecca

Open Discussion: The Good, the Bad, & the Ugly—of Middlemarch

We have one week left on our first book, Middlemarch. Now it’s time to let loose. Tell me what you think. Did you love it? Did you hate it? Or are your feelings more mixed?

View 33 comments →

Loading more posts…